A Pulitzer Prize-winning newspaper
Log in
Subscribe

Oh, chocolate, my chocolate!

An ode to chocolate in three parts

Posted

I. Remembrance of chocolates past

When my dad needed to stock major appliances in the hardware store, he didn’t pay to ship them from Sioux City to Hospers. Instead, the family piled into the yellow Zwagerman Hardware pickup and headed south. After the truck was loaded, we headed downtown to go shopping.

Downtown Sioux City was an exciting place to be when I was a kid. Everything seemed big and full of wonder. All the stores were concentrated in a tight area, and the streets were full of people and cars moving with purpose. Younkers Department Store anchored the downtown at 4th and Nebraska.

This was so long ago that the elevators were operated by people. The women wore uniforms and worked a kind of joystick to line up the elevator with the floor as the door opened. Sometimes the operator had to move the car up or down for the best alignment. It looked like an important job to me, and I was sure I’d never be skilled enough to do it.

After we shopped or looked (mostly just looked) for clothing on one of the upper floors, we’d always stop at the candy counter, a square of department store real estate located near the front doors. Its glass cases gleamed with beautiful confections, but Dad always bought the same two or three items: chocolate stars, chocolate-covered peanuts, and sometimes, chocolate clusters.

The Younkers worker would dig her shiny metal scoop into the chocolate mounds and slide the candy into white paper bags with a satisfying whoosh. The pieces softly thudded into the bottoms of the bags. Treasure!

In the truck, heading home, we’d eat the treats by the dashboard light, crinkling the bags as we dug in for another creamy or crunchy piece. Mom didn’t even scold about ruining our supper because she was partaking, too.

II. Mock chocolate

I remember carob, which was the crunchy granola answer to chocolate, but carob never went mainstream. Carob, which is nothing like chocolate, could never satisfy like cacao cum cocoa powder cum cocoa butter. Perhaps it’s because carob has no theobromine and no caffeine. In the world of chocolate, carob is a fun-hater.

Here’s why. Carob and cacao are both plants but unrelated. In fact, carob is a relative to the American locust tree.

I grew up hearing that John the Baptist ate honey and locusts, and we were given to believe that the locusts he ate were insects. Carob and locust trees look enough alike that one might mix them up.  It’s far more likely that ol’ J the B ate carob or something similar, making him the original hippie.

INTERLUDE

Oh, chocolate, chocolate! I love you so.

Oh, chocolate, chocolate! Where did you go?

III. Chocolate is not chocolate anymore

Lately, my daily dose of M&Ms has tasted off. It hasn’t stopped me from eating them, but I grumble while doing so. They just don’t taste right. Have they sat too long in a warehouse in Kankakee?

Turns out the chocolate you and I have long enjoyed is probably less chocolate and more other stuff. Climate change is affecting the world’s cacao output and it’s in crisis.

Cacao is also precious. It is only grown in a few countries in western Africa, like Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana because the ideal conditions only exist there. Until recently, anyway.

Rising temperatures and shifting rainfall patterns aren’t the only problem. A virus called swollen root disease is also affecting cacao trees even as demand for chocolate grows.

I’ve left out the most important factor in the story: greed. Candy companies have historically exploited the small farmers who grow cacao by paying them low wages. At a time when the farmers and their stocks of trees are aging and new varieties of cacao might be formulated farmers don’t have the means to make necessary changes.

There just isn’t enough cacao to go around, so if you’ve noticed that your M&Ms bag has more air and less candy, now you know why. If your Three Musketeers bar seems smaller, now you know why. If your Snickers seems to have an ever thinner chocolate coating, now you know why. And if you’ve stopped buying chocolate because it’s so expensive, now you know why.

If, like me, you’ve noticed that the same chocolatey-smooth mouth feel isn’t there, it’s probably because you and I are eating less real chocolate. We are probably eating something called compound-chocolate, but compound-chocolate is another way of saying not-really-chocolate or much-less-chocolate. Instead of cocoa butter, candy makers might be using animal fats to substitute. There might be a little of the real cocoa powder or butter mixed in but at a lower percentage.

So, the heyday of chocolate made from cacao may be fading. According to seriouseats.com, a food and drink website, “[r]esearchers and startups are experimenting with ingredients including fermented grains, sunflower seeds, carob, tiger nuts, and legumes” to serve as chocolate substitutes.

Fermented grains. Doesn’t that sound yummy. Wait, tiger nuts? I had to google to discover that tiger nuts are (get your mind out of the gutter) actually a kind of tuber. Tubers! You know, like potatoes. Does this mean that in some future Halloween we’ll be handing out Three Tuberteers?

Researchers are even looking at legumes as chocolate substitutes. Now, I like legumes but in soups and salads, not in a bar shape in a shiny wrapper carrying a name like Edamame Way.

Years ago, a friend gave me a container of sipping chocolate for Christmas. It was rich and decadent, just the way I like my chocolate. I savored the contents of that small tin for months.

Somehow, sipping powdered chickpeas is just not going to cut it.

Joan Zwagerman wonders if she needs to stockpile cocoa powder.

The Skinny, Joan Zwagerman

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here